Freelance writers operate on
a basis of trust. Whether accepting commissions or sending
off unsolicited material to likely buyers, they probably
concentrate far more on the quality of their output and
their marketing effort than on the honesty of buyers. In
the days when writers worked primarily for publications
in their country of residence, it was easier to check the
soundness of potential buyers of material, even if the checks
were fairly casual, such as recommendations from other writers.
Now, however, the opportunities afforded by the Internet,
electronic publishing and e-mail mean that writers quite
literally have the world as their market. Over the past
few years I have sold material to Hong Kong, Singapore,
the USA, France, Belgium, Jordan and the UK.
To be fair, I have only twice encountered problems over
payment. On one occasion I received the promised cheque
but unfortunately it was of the bouncing variety and I ended
up paying bank charges for the privilege of trying to cash
it. I decided that in this case the publisher, who did not
respond to my requests for explanation, had forfeited the
restrictions imposed in the contract and I sold the article
elsewhere. On the second occasion I made repeated requests
for payment and was promised that the cheque was on its
way. However, no payment ever arrived and I am not sure
how to go about recovering my money.
Nick Inman, now resident in France, highlights the difficulties
surrounding payment of freelance writers in Europe:
You'd have thought that it would be easy to collect a debt
in the civilised countries of the European Union and that
the National Union of Journalists (NUJ) would help you to
do it. But not always so. I am particularly concerned about
the burgeoning expatriate press, the worst of which behaves
as if it were a entity unto its own: out of the reach of
British law and the NUJ's solicitors; and not quite a full
member (because of the language) of the host country's own
media. Besides which, many countries of Europe barely understand
the concept of a freelance contributor. But it shouldn't
matter who you are or where you choose to live: a debt is
a debt. The unpaid supplier has legal right on his side
under EU regulations which came into force last August:
these state that a client has to pay you 30 days after he
(or she or it) becomes aware of how much he owes you, or
after you have delivered the work - whichever date is the
later. This rule can be overridden by agreement between
you but that is the only legitimate excuse for late payment.
In theory then, non-payment, particularly within Europe,
shouldn't be a problem. But it still happens. So what is
the answer? First, I suggest the freelance writer needs
to put in place some means of self-protection. Work out
a simple set of terms and conditions and, whenever a new
client is proposing work, send these to the client and ask
for them to be signed and returned to you before you deliver
anything. Say what your fees are and when you require the
payment but also say what you undertake to do on behalf
of the client. A further safeguard is to request an advance
payment of 25 - 30% of the agreed fee. If, on the other
hand, the client has a contract, look carefully at the payment
provisions and ensure that they are acceptable to you.
Of course, these measures cannot guarantee that you will
be fairly treated but they show the client that you have
a professional attitude not just to your work, but to the
way you operate. If you still find yourself the victim of
a non-paying client what can you do? First, you can find
out what system exists in the country where the client does
business for the collection of bad debts. In the UK the
Small Claims Court hears claims for bad debts up to £5
000. It is possible to obtain assistance with such claims
online through a website: http://www.small-claims.co.uk/
. France also has an equivalent of the Small Claims system
in the huissier de justice (www.huissier-justice.fr). Often
mere mention of the huissier is enough to make French debtors
pay up.
Spain is testing out similar legislation but you have to
live in the country to take advantage of it. 'Spain does
now have a new small-claims system in place,' explains Valerie
Collins, based in Barcelona; 'You can go straight to the
court and file a claim for non payment without having to
hire a solicitor. You have to have issued a formal invoice,
and have proof that you have rendered the service invoiced
for (in our case, proof of publication). If you're owed
money by a Spanish company but are not resident in Spain,
you would have to give power of attorney to someone domiciled
here if you wanted to file for payment, as they won't send
legal notifications outside Spain.'
The disadvantage of these systems is that the claimant
sometimes incurs costs, so even if the money is eventually
recovered, part of it will have been eaten away by charges.
So, the poor writer suffers yet again as, no doubt, the
fees payable are already liable to the outrageously high
charges made by banks when they transfer funds from one
country to another.
Other routes are to join journalists' and writers' unions
and associations. These, however, may provide little more
than moral support unless the claim is really big and they
think it worth supporting a claimant for the benefit of
the membership as a whole. As a last resort, I suppose freelance
writers could co-operate by sharing the names of clients
who do not pay. It might be unwise to publish such a list
openly in case the publisher became liable to libel charges,
but I imagine it would be possible to set up an email list
through which writers could distribute names on the basis
of 'caution is advised before working with X'. |